Free domestic shipping on every order · Fast turnaround · Printed in Brooklyn, NY

Find your next favorite.

Looking for something unique? Create a custom shirt.

I’m With Creepy, I’m With Creepier Set to Pinterest (opens in a new window)

Matching setFunny

I’m With Creepy, I’m With Creepier Set

4.9 from 8,710 Etsy reviews8,192 five-star reviews · 38K+ shop sales

$40.99

Printed in BrooklynBy OneWayTshirts

Free domestic shippingPrinted in Brooklyn

I’m with creepy, I’m with creepier. A funny matching Halloween costume set for couples who are a little odd together.

Make it yours.Find your fit
  • Free domestic shippingtracked, on every order
  • Fast turnaroundprinted to order in our Brooklyn shop
  • 14-day returnseasy exchanges

Free domestic shipping · Fast turnaround14-day returns & exchangesShipping & returns

Details & fabric

A funny matching Halloween costume set for couples who are a little odd together.

  • "I'm With Creepy, I'm With Creepier" design
  • 100% cotton
  • Unisex fit
  • Printed in Brooklyn, NY
Size & fit

See the size chart in the product photos, or ask us and we will help you pick.

Shipping & returns

Free domestic shipping on every order, with tracking, and a fast turnaround from our Brooklyn shop. Delivery times depend on the carrier and are estimates. Returns and exchanges within 14 days. Personalized shirts are made to order, so they cannot be returned for a change of mind or a wrong size.

Shipping & returns policy

Care
  • Wash inside out
  • Do not bleach
  • Hang dry for best results, or tumble dry low
  • Do not iron the print

From our Etsy shop

4.9 from 8,710 Etsy reviews

A few words from customers about our shirts and shop.

My husband laughed out loud when he opened this tshirt! Great gift and fast shipping!
KariEtsy review · 2025
We Love This tee shirt!! It’s so funny, my husband gets lots of compliments when wearing it, and it’s good quality, fits true to size!
SusanEtsy review · 2023
Shipping went well. Looks just as pictured and well made. The green is a great color. My husband loved the gift. Perfect for the gun range.
IanEtsy review · 2023
Live from our Brooklyn shop

How it’s made

Printed for you
in Brooklyn.

  1. 1
    Printed to order

    Your shirt is printed on our own direct-to-garment printer in Brooklyn, NY.

  2. 2
    Packed by our team

    Folded and packed by the same small team that printed it. No warehouse, no middleman.

  3. 3
    Free domestic shipping, fast turnaround

    Printed in our Brooklyn shop and shipped quickly, with tracking by email the moment it ships.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LOVE.

Explore the collection
ONEWAY / FIT GUIDE

Find your fit.

Start with a shirt you already love.

  1. Lay it flat without stretching the fabric.
  2. Measure across the chest, just below the sleeves.
  3. Measure from the top of the shoulder to the hem.

Compare these measurements with the size chart in the product photos.

Read the full size guide